Marital Rape in India: Legal Loopholes and Societal Impact
Marital rape remains a contentious issue in many parts of the world. It involves non-consensual sexual acts between a husband and wife. This article delves into the complexities surrounding marital rape in India, its legal status, and its profound societal implications, with a focus on data-driven examples and a call to action.
Table of Contents
Introduction
The issue of marital rape in India, or वैवाहिक बलात्कार, is deeply rooted in societal power dynamics and traditional norms. It is a sensitive subject, often overlooked or justified by outdated beliefs about marriage and consent. In the 21st century, shouldn’t bodily autonomy be a fundamental right, regardless of marital status? This article aims to shed light on this critical issue, exploring its definition, legal status in India, and the patriarchal structures that perpetuate it. The goal is to foster understanding and advocate for change, ensuring that women have autonomy over their bodies and lives.
What is Marital Rape?
Marital rape is generally defined as any non-consensual sexual act performed by a husband on his wife. This lack of consent is what differentiates it from consensual sexual relations within a marriage. Despite the existence of a marital bond, every individual has the right to bodily autonomy. Violating this autonomy constitutes a form of sexual violence.
It is a type of domestic abuse and sexual assault. For many women, it is a painful reality, often shrouded in silence due to social stigma and legal loopholes.
Patriarchal Roots of Marital Rape
The concept of marital rape in India is intertwined with patriarchal structures prevalent in many societies, including India. These systems grant men significant control over women and their bodies, often viewing wives as property. This mindset fosters an environment where a husband’s sexual desires are prioritized over a wife’s consent, leading to the justification or denial of marital rape.
In such patriarchal societies, it is often believed that a woman’s primary duty is to fulfill her husband’s desires, regardless of her own feelings or consent. This belief system normalizes marital rape, making it difficult for women to recognize and report the abuse they suffer.
Legal Landscape in India for Marital Rape
The legal status of marital rape in India is complex and controversial. Currently, marital rape is not recognized as a crime under Indian law. This exemption is primarily due to the exception granted in Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code, which defines rape.
Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code
Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) defines rape but includes an exception that exempts sexual intercourse by a man with his own wife, provided she is above a certain age (currently 18 years). This exception has been a major point of contention, as it effectively legalizes marital rape in India.
This definition is rooted in laws created during British colonial rule. The debate regarding the validity of this exception continues to persist in India’s legal and social spaces.
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita on Marital Rape
The newly introduced Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), which aims to replace the IPC, retains the same exception for marital rape. This means that the legal status of marital rape in India remains unchanged under the new legal framework.
Under the BNS, what was Section 375 IPC is now Section 63, with the same exception continuing to protect husbands from prosecution for non-consensual sexual acts with their wives.
Judicial Perspectives
The issue of marital rape has been brought before the Indian judiciary on numerous occasions, leading to varying perspectives and judgments. This has resulted in a complex and often contradictory legal landscape.
High Court Split Verdicts on Marital Rape
In 2022, the Delhi High Court delivered a split verdict on the issue of marital rape. One judge argued for the removal of the exception for marital rape, while the other favored retaining it. This division highlighted the deep-seated disagreements within the judiciary regarding this issue.
Similarly, the Karnataka High Court has also taken a different stance, refusing to quash rape charges against a husband, thereby indicating a divergence in judicial opinion across different high courts.
Supreme Court’s Intervention
Given the conflicting judgments from various high courts, the Supreme Court of India has intervened to provide clarity on the legal status of marital rape in India. The Supreme Court has repeatedly asked the central government to clarify its stance on the issue.
The Supreme Court’s involvement underscores the significance of this issue and the need for a consistent legal framework.
Government’s Stance on Marital Rape
The Indian government has consistently opposed the criminalization of marital rape, citing concerns about the potential destabilization of the institution of marriage and the possibility of misuse of such a law.
Historical Opposition of Criminalising Marital Rape in India
The government’s opposition to criminalizing marital rape dates back to 2016 when it rejected the idea of making marital rape a crime. This stance was reiterated in 2017 and again in 2024 when the Supreme Court sought clarification on the government’s position.
This consistent opposition highlights the deeply entrenched patriarchal beliefs within the government and the societal reluctance to recognize marital rape as a crime.
Current Justification
In its affidavits to the Supreme Court, the central government has argued that existing laws already provide sufficient remedies for married women facing sexual violence. It has also stated that criminalizing marital rape would be overly harsh and inconsistent with the institution of marriage.
The government also raises concerns about the potential for false accusations and the impact on family life, suggesting that the issue is more social than legal and should be addressed through societal means rather than legal intervention.
International Perspective
While marital rape remains a legal gray area in India, many countries around the world have recognized it as a crime. This global trend highlights the evolving understanding of marital relationships and the importance of consent in all sexual interactions.
Global Recognition
Several countries have criminalized marital rape, starting with the Soviet Union in 1922. Poland followed in 1932, and many Western nations, including the United Kingdom and the United States, criminalized marital rape in the late 20th century.
As of 2019, over 150 countries have recognized marital rape as a crime. These legal reforms reflect a global movement towards recognizing women’s rights and bodily autonomy within marriage.
India as an Exception
India remains one of the few countries where marital rape in India is not a crime. This puts Indian women at a disadvantage compared to their counterparts in other nations, where they have legal recourse against spousal sexual violence.
This also raises questions about India’s commitment to international human rights standards and its obligations to protect women from all forms of violence.
Data and Statistics
The true extent of marital rape in India is difficult to ascertain due to the lack of legal recognition and the social stigma surrounding the issue. However, available data and surveys provide some insight into the prevalence of sexual violence within marriage.
Is marriage a contract where consent is a one-time given, or is it a continuous agreement? If we demand consent for every financial transaction, why not for physical intimacy?
National Family Health Survey
According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS), a significant percentage of married women in India have experienced sexual violence from their husbands. The NFHS data reveals that a substantial proportion of women between 18 and 39 years have faced sexual violence from their husbands. This data underscores the severity of the problem and the urgent need for legal and social interventions.
These statistics highlight the pervasive nature of sexual violence within marriage and the urgent need for legal recognition and protection.
Dowry Deaths
There is another form of domestic violence that is correlated to marital rape: Dowry deaths. “Dowry” refers to the practice where the bride’s family provides gifts or property to the groom’s family upon marriage. Sadly, statistics indicate a high rate of “dowry deaths,” where wives are killed due to insufficient dowry or are pushed to commit suicide. Those that survive are often forced to live a life of marital rape.
These figures indicate a deeply troubling trend that requires immediate and comprehensive action.
Victims’ Experiences
The experiences of women who have survived marital rape are often marked by trauma, isolation, and a lack of legal recourse. The data on dowry deaths and the NFHS surveys only paint a partial picture; the true impact is felt in the lives of these women. Many women are unaware that what they are experiencing is continuous abuse, further compounding their suffering.
One counselor describes how many women only realize they have been victims of marital rape when seeking counseling for marital problems. They often do not know that what has been happening to them is a crime. This lack of awareness highlights the need for education and awareness campaigns to inform women about their rights and the nature of marital rape.
Role of the Women’s Commission
The National Commission for Women (NCW) plays a crucial role in advocating for women’s rights and addressing issues of violence against women. However, the NCW’s stance on marital rape has been controversial, with some reports suggesting that the commission has favored maintaining the exception for marital rape.
This stance has drawn criticism, as it appears to prioritize preserving the institution of marriage over protecting women from sexual violence. It also raises questions about the commission’s commitment to its mandate of promoting and protecting women’s rights.
Alternative Views
There is a counter narrative that marital rape should not be against law. It is claimed that there are many misuses of the law related to Dowry, and this will increase the number of these false complaints against the male counterpart
They also claimed that since physical relationship is a basic expectation for marriage, women should not be able to opt out of getting intimate. They argue against instution of marriage. Consent is assumed the moment marriage is done.
Conclusion
The issue of marital rape demands urgent attention and action. We must advocate for legal reforms that recognize marital rape as a crime and provide women with the protection and justice they deserve. Some may argue with their traditional belives. But they do agree that violence is bad.
It’s essential to start from home. Respect your partner. If they say no to any kind of physical relationship. It’s No
Disclaimer:
- Brahmin: In the context of this discussion, it refers to the ideology or system of thought often associated with Brahminical traditions, which may include hierarchical social structures and patriarchal norms.
- Hindu: Refers to individuals, beliefs, and cultural practices associated with Hinduism. In this context, it is not used to generalize all Hindus but to address specific instances of discrimination, patriarchy or social issues as they relate to certain Hindu practices or ideologies.
- Dalit: A term used to refer to members of the lowest castes in India.
- OBC: Other Backward Classes, a collective term used by the Indian government to classify castes which are socially and educationally disadvantaged.
What can you do?
- Raise Awareness: Speak out against marital rape and challenge the social norms that perpetuate it.
- Support Organizations: Support organizations working to end gender-based violence and provide assistance to survivors of sexual assault. Research local organizations that are working towards to make a change. Support them with donation and/or volunteering.
- Advocate for Change: Contact your elected officials and urge them to support legal reforms that criminalize marital rape.
- Educate Yourself and Others: Learn more about the issue of marital rape and share your knowledge with others to foster greater understanding and empathy.
By working together, we can create a society where all women are safe, respected, and empowered to exercise their right to bodily autonomy. Support us by sharing it with your friends and family.
Read more about the Supreme Court Judgements and it’s impact on Bahujan Rights.
Find out more about vegetarianism being used as a casteist weapon.
Do you disagree with this article? If you have strong evidence to back up your claims, we invite you to join our live debates every Sunday, Tuesday, and Thursday on YouTube. Let’s engage in a respectful, evidence-based discussion to uncover the truth. Watch the latest debate on this topic below and share your perspective!
